John Rimmer
MUFOB volume 6, number 3, January 1974
The majority of small local UFO groups~operating at present in this country do little practical work in the
field of UFO research, as opposed to speculation.
Some groups. are however making serious efforts to catalogue and co-ordinate sighting reports in their
districts. One such is the Scunthorpe UFO Research Society, who are compiling a catalogue of all UFO reports in
the Scunthorpe and North Lincolnshire area, and subjecting them to some basic statistical analysis.
This work
is as yet only in its infancy, and it is too soon for any statistical conclusions to be drawn from the small
sample of sightings that have been dealt with. However the method used by the Group could be emulated by any
other local group or individual, and we are giving them in some detail to suggest to some of the more inactive
groups the sort of work on which they could be profitably engaged.
There is however little point in any group or individual compiling reports and statistics, or doing any basic
research, if this work is known only to a small circle. There is a crying need for some high quality research
journals to disseminate the basic data amongst those engaged on UFO research. This is not being done at
present.
Firstly, many of the journals are just mouthpieces for group gossip and idle speculation, and do not print
articles unless the writer is a member of the group, or subscribes to its views, or has not quarrelled with the
editor at some time in the past.
Secondly, the work may be too technical and specialised to be practical for the larger, general circulation
journals, which depend on their subscribers for their economic viability. Although FSR, for instance has in the
past published many very important and highly technical articles it ts obvious that an FSR composed entirely of
such erudite material would rapidly lose a high proportion of its paying customers.
The answer to this problem is not to be found, I fear, within the existing group system. Although individua1
groups (or perhaps more accurately, individuals within groups) may be doing excellent work, this is too often
fragmented by the petty jealousies that bedevil ufology. The need is not for the promotion of ever more UFO
groups with their plethora of title-seekers, but for an adequate system of publishing the research and findings
of those who are making' some contribution to ufology.
Recent proposals made to BUFORA by people who were asked
to suggest a publishing policy for the Association were poo-poohed by a previous editor of their journal, who
dismissed them out of hand as 'impractical and ludicrous'. In truth they were not only practical but essential
if UFO research and its findings is to be anything more than the private property of a handful of researchers.
BUFORA would be better employed concentrating its efforts on the organisation and dissemination of
information than dissipating its energies on observatories, for which there seems to be no practical function
in ufology, and devising titles for superannuated officers.
A major fault of the group system is the failure of many defunct groups to hand on their sighting reports and
other material to successor organisations in their areas. This leads to much wasteful duplication of effort,
and seems to be yet another symptom of the extraordinary jealousy and secrecy that surrounds UFO investigation
in this country.
As has been emphasised throughout this analysis of the Scunthorpe sightings, this is based on a very small
sample of 'positive' reports, which is on its own too small to draw any conclusions. However a properly
constituted central clearing house could be receiving similar reports from groups and individuals throughout
the country, producing a more representative sample, from which more significant statistical studies could be
drawn" At present this is not happening, certainly not to tho extent to which it is happening in France, Spain,
or the Midwestern states of the USA. This appears to be due in equal part to the lack of any determined effort
by the major UFO groups to co-ordinate reports sent in to them, (indeed, when the Scunthorpe reports were
submitted to one of the major journals they were rejected in cursory fashion) and to the general apathy of most
local groups to doing anything other than sit around in their meeting rooms swapping idle speculations. In
these circumstances the serious researcher is often discouraged by the sheer weight of apathy and the
impossibility of either publishing his own work, or reading the findings of others.
I do not want to appear totally negative however, and I do appreciate that much good material is being
published, especially by the journals that are not attached to any particular group. But they are subject to
the problems of keeping their subscribers happy, and many of these subscribers are only interested in ufology
in a very superficial manner. The immediate need, as far as statistical analysis of reports is concerned, is a
medium for the publication of material such as Nigel Watson's Scunthorpe catalogue and analysis" It may seen
incredible, but there is at the moment no British journal aiming to record every publicly notified UFO sighting
in this country. The UFOLOG section of BUFORA Journal now just publishes cases dealt with by the Association,
Flying Saucer Review's 'Round Up' is an attempt to summarise major sightings throughout the world and cannot,
for space reasons alone, attempt a total summary of all British events. This very fundamental lack of a
source of raw data is an inhibiting factor to serious UFO research in Britain today.
MUFOB has never been primarily a source of UFO sightings nationally, its main function is as a forum for ideas
and comment and as a medium for the publication of research. The pages of this Bulletin are always open to the
kind of large-scale statistical analysis or specialised technical article, that the larger circulation journals
may have to think twice about publishing.
INTRODUCTION TO THE SCUNTHORPE CATALOGUE
NIGEL WATSON
This is a catalogue of 19 Scunthorpe UFO reports covering a period of 19 years, taken from a file of nearly 50
reports. The 30 reports not included will constitute a future analysis of negative sightings in the Scunthorpe
area. The catalogue is completed at the beginning of 1973 and I hope to update all this information once every
year or so, depending on the number of reports received. It is advisable that readers see Peter Rogerson's
article in MUFOB 5:4, in which he gives his introduction to the International Catalogue of Type I Reports.
All reports coming into the group are recorded briefly on a standard form in this format:
Date:
Location:
Approximate Duration of Sighting:
Location:
Approximate Duration of Sighting:
Time
Outline description of event: (Case 3/0 given as example) Whilst walking near the (Normanby Park steel) works,
Mr Higson's dog, an Alsatian, began to whine for no apparent reason. He glanced to his left and saw, 200 ft.
up, drifting to the right, an object round in shape and glowing. It then inclined to an angle of 45 degrees and
moved slowly at first, then shot faster into the sky, becoming a point of light.
Source of report and interviewer (if any):
Name, age and address of witness:
The file of sightings was tabulated by various criteria. A time distribution chart shows that the sightings
conform to the general pattern that has been observed by Vallee and others. Of the 12 sightings in which the
time was known exactly, five occurred between 1700hrs and 1830hrs, six occurred between 2000hrs and 2400hrs, and only one
occurred after 2400hrs.
An age pyramid of witnesses was drawn up, which also broadly corresponded to those discovered by Vallee and
Ballester Olmos. This showed that three witnesses were under 10 years of age. Seven were between 10 and 20;
eight between age 20 and 30; two aged from 30 to 40; one each between 40 and 50 and 50 and 60, and
two aged between 70 and 80.
A study of the activities of primary witnesses at the times of the sightings reveals that 12 were out walking;
three were at home; one at school; and two not known. Interestingly only one witness in the 19 cases investigated
was on a vehicle at the time of the sighting? and that was a bicycle.
The number of witnesses to individual sightings also corresponds to the findings of researchers working on
larger samples.
Most of the cases 13, had only one witness. Two cases had two witnesses, three cases had three
witnesses, and one case had five witnesses. The disparity in the number of male witnesses to female seems to be
artificially exaggerated by the small sample available for analysis, males outnumbering females by 20 to 11.
The majority of cases dealt with in this sample occurred in the 1971 'flap', the distribution being thus:
11 Nov 1953 - 1
Winter 1968 - 1
26 Apr 1969 - 1
-- Dec 1969 - 1
20 Nov 1970 - 2
05 Aug 1971 - 1
25 Oct 1971 - 1
27 Oct 1971 - 4
28 Oct 1971 - 2
18 Nov 1971 - 2
19 Nov 1971 - 1
17 Aug 1972 - 1
03 Oct 1972 - 1
The concentration of the sightings on the 1971 flap merely reflects the period in which the Scunthorpe Society
was active. It is important that any local group should make a thorough investigation of local newspapers to
discover the historical background of UFO activities in its neighbourhood.