Showing posts with label MUFOB 04 05. Show all posts
Showing posts with label MUFOB 04 05. Show all posts

Wednesday, 19 March 2014

The New Ufology: A Critique. Part One

Alan Sharp
Merseyside UFO Bulletin, volume 4, number 5, December 1971.
 
In a previous article which dealt with certain aspects of the book Operation Trojan Horse, I pointed out a few of the factual errors and misleading statements which seemed to me to cast doubt on the value of this book as a serious contribution to the understanding of UFO phenomena, Some of my comments were a little pedantic and I am not over-fond. of appeals to authority, but these quibbles apart I have no doubt that my  criticisms were amply justified.

The New Ufology: A Critique. Part Two

Alan Sharp
Merseyside UFO Bulletin, volume 4, number 5, December 1971
 
Incredible though it may seem Vallee pursues the subject of fairy rings as if he actually believes that they have a supernatural origin and regales his readers with information like the following: "Another writer, reporting on Scandinavian legends, noted that elves are depicted there as beings with oversize heads, tiny legs and long arms. They are responsible for the bright green circles called elf-dans (or fairy rings) Which one sees on the lawns." (Passport to Magonia pp 37-39).