MUFOB New Series 6, Spring 1977
Although the number of those with personal experience of UFOs seems quite large, one must remember that all experiences are not reported. In the Colorado sample, only thirteen percent of those who sighted a UFO reported it to other than family or friends(Lee, 1968, p226) (1). In evaluating information from official agencies this selection factor must be borne in mind. And in fact to get a true idea of the amount of ‘filtering’, one can compare the (about) 12,000 reports which the US Air Force received between 1950 and 1969 (Condon) with the number they should have received if all the reports had been transmitted.
Of 3.75 million (estimated) people who have seen UFOs, the Colorado study found that 13 per cent, or about 490,000, had reported their sightings. If the Air Force received, over the same period, about 12,000 reports, then there must have been an enormous attrition of reports when passing through the channels, even considering multiple-witness reports. Thus anywhere from one in fifty to one in three hundred (2) sightings may be represented by an official (USAF) report. Consequently, conclusions from Air Force data about UFOs must bear this fact in mind.
What do we know about the representativeness of the reports the US Air Force receives? Can we assume that only the best reports are passed on? To attempt answers to these questions we must examine both the reasons for reporting and those for non-reporting. Sighters whose reports reached the Colorado Project’s files indicated that the two strongest motives were 1) the feeling that strange objects should be reported, and 2) “I would want to know what it was” (Lee, 1968, p227) Given that the first motivation, mentioned by 43 per-cent of the sighters, could be seen as involving a sense of civic duty, one can well sense the bitterness and frustration felt by those making the reports when they are labeled liars or mentally ill. (3) Reporting is a risky business, and making a report is often an act of considerable courage.
The decision to report or not probably involves calculations about the positive and negative consequences that will personally accrue if a report is made. Many of those who have high credibility and are ‘high discriminators’ are precisely those who have the most to lose by making a report. Single-person sightings are probably under-represented in reports, since a greater degree of scepticism is applied to events that were witnessed by only one person. Even close kin may not believe ones unless it was witnessed by someone else (Fuller, 1966, pp.13,140,176; Michel, 1958, p.43). The more impressive a particular UFO sighting is, the more information the report is likely to yield — and the greater the scepticism on is likely to meet in reporting it. We have already mentioned the convincing effect that personal experience has on unbelievers. A good proxy for personal experience is the experience of a close friend or a peer. Other persons with whom there is a high identification tend to be believed more often than strangers — even when such strangers are more knowledgeable than one’s friends and peers. (4)
There is also a tendency for certain kinds of information to circulate only informally along colleague groups. This is particularly important in the case of scientists, since there observations are given special weight by both other scientists, and by the public at large. Page (1968) begins an article on detection of UFOs by noting that no astronomical photograph has recorded a UFO. This assertion is in itself interesting, as the Vallées (1966) had already indicated that more than one astronomical photograph was in existence and in fact one of them is reduced in their book. But the assertion is even more interesting in that Page admits in a footnote that he has been told informally that ‘anomalous trails’ had appeared on one set of photographs (5) which had not been reported in the public literature, and that in any case no special search for anomalies had been made. It is thus possible that an astronomer will know relatively little about colleagues’ observations of UFOs even if he has an active interest in them.
The fear of ridicule predisposes many scientists against reporting. Berthold Schwartz, a psychiatrist, notes that he interviewed a physicist who is now Professor and chairman of a university department. Although this person had experienced a UFO sighting at close range which he credited with a significant influence on his life, few of his colleagues were aware that he had had such an experience (Schwartz, 1972). Nor would he allow his name to be used in Schwartz’s writings. In my own interviews with about two dozen physicists and chemists in a university setting, I came across one case in which an apparently prominent physicist observed what would be called a “cloud cigar” in the jargon of ufology. He had not publicised the fact however, and had in fact sworn his friends to secrecy. Thus many reports — how many it is impossible to know — by scientists are kept not only from the public but from their colleagues at large. And the informal policies of scientific journals (see Hartmann, 1968, p.584) are such that the journals are unlikely to accept the papers of scientists who try to publish them. All of which contributes to the public and scientific impression that UFOs are not seen by astronomers. (see Jones, 1968a, p.230)
This tendency extends to the international concealment of research projects on UFOs carried out by scientists and others. Ruppelt (1956) mentions two cases of such concealment, both dealing with the relation of UFOs to exceptionally high atmospheric radiation. In one case a group of scientists at an Atomic Energy Commission laboratory had noticed that huge jumps in background radiation tended to be associated with local UFO sightings. Some years later they set up a recording apparatus on a local mountain, and found that in the one case in which a UFO had been seen near the mountain their recording apparatus showed a large jump in radiation level (see pp.264-270). In the second case a military installation found consistently that its radiation monitoring equipment tended to show higher radiation in areas where UFOs had been seen (pp. 270-271). In both cases no official report was made of the activities of these groups.
If UFOs were, for instance, outer-space vehicles, then those reports which involved close proximity to UFOs, or contact with their “operators” would be the most valuable, since they would yield the most information on the nature of the craft and their occupants. Since such reports are often sensational, however, and the rapporteursoften make money on the basis of their testimony, reports of contacts tend to be suspect. Project Blue Book had an admirably simple method of dealing with such reports they went into a file marked ‘crackpot’. Many amateur UFO investigation organisations also reject such reports (Vallée, 1966, pp 232-234).
It was previously the belief of the author of this paper that contactees represented a mixed group of hoaxers and psychotics. This may in fact be the case; but even if it is, the matter is more complex than it at first appears. Many contactees are apparently ‘silent’ According to his own account, Keel (1970, p.212) interviewed over 200 of them who had previously not divulged their experiences in a public way. (6) He estimates that they may number as many as 50,000 throughout the USA, although he does not disclose the basis for this estimate.
Other contactees are inspired to attempt assassinations (Vallée, 1969, p.131); may play major roles in religious “miracles”, such as the one in Fatima, Portugal in 1915 (see e.g. Keel, 1970, pp.255-264); or even conspire to overthrow governments (Keel, 1970, pp.280-281). Depending on how broadly one wishes to define “Contactee”, one might consider that many of the world’s major and minor religions were started by alleged or actual contactee exper-iences. The real extent of the contactee phenomenon is beyond the scope of this paper, and can only be appreciated by reading Vallée and Keel.
The above considerations make it unlikely that the official reports represent a random sample of UFO experiences and even less likely that they represent the most informative reports. Ruppelt, while Director of Project Blue Book, once found out about a very important sighting (Ruppelt, 1956, pp.139-141) while riding on a plane with a man who had no idea who Ruppelt was; Ruppelt was the first and perhaps the only person he had confided in, because he was a complete stranger. This sighting, which correlated with another previously uncorroborated sighting, reached Ruppelt by coincidence. How many other sightings are not so serendipitously communicated? One does not know. It is clear though, that much that is important comes to light only after intensive search or completely by accident. Reporting is thus a haphazard process, and much filtering of reports takes place at the source.
It would be undesirable to suggest that all suppression of reports is unjustified. Clearly, society’s information-processing mechanisms are limited, and might be overloaded if all apparent anomalies were scrupulously reported. Hence, in making a decision as to whether to report or not, the individual may also be concerned with over-burdening social intelligent mechanisms. The more striking the observation, of course, the less legitimate this rationale becomes. My personal impression is that there are as many errors of overcaution in reporting as there are of temerity.
Contagion. Experience Generation vs. Report Release.
A point often advanced in favour of the hypothesis that waves of UFO sightings are due to hysterical contagion is that the release of a single prominent report prompts the release of many more. One distinction however, must be made that is often overlooked in this matter. Reporting may well be contagious, in the sense that a person may be motivated to report a UFO if other reports are being made. This does not necessarily imply, though, that the number of experiences of UFOs increases when this happens – which would be the case if hysterical contagion were involved. Rather, all that one can say is that the propensity to report increases. This is likely to mean that the conditional probability of reporting, given an experience, will increase; and it is likely to mean that reports which are hoaxes will increase as well.
Earlier we have indicated the small ratio of reports to primary experiences. There exists at any time, then, a large number of reports which can be “shaken loose” by a newspaper article, magazine or book. It is by no means true that the reports which are thus elicited are all second rate either. Heuvelmans, in his work on sea-serpents (1968), has noted that many good reports seem to be communicated after someone breaks the ice and tells about their sighting; others are then likely to write to the magazine or author of the article and relate their own experience. This sort of “report release” phenomenon may be involved in information about other kinds of anomalies as well.
Of course, if hysterical contagion is involved, all the reports which come in should refer to experiences which postdate the original report. Report release, on the other hand, is likely to involve reports that may be years old. Yet even this criterion is not unequivocal, since experiences after the original report are more likely to be reported than ones before it. And in the case where private, unpublicised experiences take place before the initial report is made (7), is the hypothesis of hysterical contagion still tenable? This is a question which sociologists might fruitfully attack withboth empirical studies and mathematical models, since the phenomenon of hysterical contagion often manifests itself in quite different ways, as one can see from the diverse kinds of collective behaviour grouped under this label (see the review in Kerckhoff & Back, 1968, ch.2); from bodily symptoms which are transmitted through personal observations to imagined incidents which are suggested by newspaper stories. Even neuroses like “shell shock” may be the result of social contagion.
Behaviour of Official Agencies
So far we have been largely concerned with those who have experiences with and report UFOs. Clearly one component of reporting, though, is the expected reaction of those to whom the report is made. We have already alluded to the role of communication media in generating reports, but government agencies also have a role in eliciting or discouraging reports. This role is particularly important where organisations, including other agencies, are in a position to make repeated UFO observations, and whose propensity to make reports will be related to the feedback they get from those who receive the reports. Ruppelt indicates in several places how important this feedback can bee in influencing the transmission or non-transmission of reports (1956 pp.146,159-161,169,10).
In looking at the interaction of official agencies, it is often useful to make a dichotomy between “locals” and “centrals”. The locals are those on the spot, in the field, who actually have the experiences. The centrals are those who have the job of interpreting the reports of the locals, often in political capitals far removed from the scene of the action. Should locals observe some anomalous phenomena and try to send a report to the centrals, trouble is almost necessarily bound to ensue. The locals consider them selves “high discriminators” and reasonably competent at evaluating what they observe. The centrals, on the other hand, have not made the observation that the locals have, consider such observations a priori impossible, and suspect that the locals are a bit barmy.
The communications from locals to centrals tend to arrive in written form, often with contextual facts and emotional ambiance extracted from them; in any case there is nothing to require the centrals to read the reports in their entirety. The centrals then suggest that the local, e.g., have been drinking too much (Ruppelt, 1956, p.99) or advise the locals about certain elementary sources of observational error that they may not have taken into account (Ruppelt, 1956, p.170). Regardless of the emotional tone of the locals’ reactions to these insults – which range from fury to despair — the reports are almost certain to stop coming, a result that the centrals do not seek to avoid.
In many cases the locals are not part of any agency, and submit reports, for instance, to the local Air Force base. If those at the base do not have a personal commitment to transmit the sightings, they may well wish to avoid unpleasant suggestions from their “centrals” and so tailor their information transmissions to match the expectations of their superiors.
Air Force officers are human, and therefore interpret their duty quite differently. Some went to great lengths not to submit a report. Others took a special delight in submitting all of the ‘easy’ ones out of a zealous loyalty to their service, because the re ‘identifieds’ they turned in, the highter would be the overall percentage of UFO reports explained. (Condon, 1968. p.22)
The centrals, too have their own higher echelons, whom they in turn must take into consideration:
The people on the UFO project began to think maybe the brass didn’t consider them too smart so they tried a new hypothesis: UFOs don’t exist. In no time they found that this was easier to prove and it got recognition. Before if an especially interesting UFO report came in and the Pentagon wanted an answer, all they’d get was an “It could be real but we can’t prove it”. Now such a request got a quick, snappy, “It was a balloon”, and feathers were stuck in caps from ATIC up to the Pentagon. Everybody felt fine. (Ruppelt, 1956, p.82)
Because of the often close dependence of agency behaviour on the perceived wishes of the higher echelons, the information which reached the latter may vary in a manner only partially related to external events, at least as such events reach the lower echelons.
Not all agency personnel, of course, act in this manner; some often persist in forwarding reports of unexplained UFO sightings in spite of the sentiments of their superiors. When official channels bog down, informal channels often are used for communication. The higher echelons are not necessarily unanimous, and those among them who refuse to accept pat answers may find sympathetic lower officers who will surreptitiously forward reports, although this will sometimes be done only on a face-to-face basis (see Ruppelt, 1956, ch,1). Here again the informal communication that takes place among colleague groups is often the main channel along which much information travels and discussion takes place.
For several months the belief that Project Blue Book was taking a negative attitude and the possibility that UFOs were interplanetary spaceships had been growing in the Pentagon, but these ideas were usually discussed only in the privacy of offices with doors that would close tight. (emphasis RW) (Ruppelt, 1956. p.196)
It nonetheless appears true, at least in the period 1947-1953, that evidence by and large was looked into, reported, or destroyed according to what it was felt the higher echelons of the US Air Force desired (Ruppelt, 1956. pp.12, 160, 176, 229). This was also true of the orientation of Project Blue Book itself during this period. Nor is such behaviour a unique property of Air Force intelligence organizations (see Wilensky, 1967, ch.3).
These internal forms of suppression, subterfuge and deceit are harmful enough to the process of social intelligence: in warfare they have often extracted high costs (Wilensky, 1967). Where public opinion is aroused, however, external forms of disinformation are resorted to as well. The so-called Robertson Panel, a group of scientists who were called to evaluate the evidence for UFOs in 1953, recommended a public debunking campaign to take the “mystery” out of UFOs. The intention of the Robertson Panel was to discourage the “poor” quality reports so that there would be more time to process “good” quality reports. It is possible, on the other hand, that what would have resulted had their recommendations been taken seriously was a decreased propensity to report, which would affect “good” as well as “poor” reports. An Air Force disinformation campaign in 1949, although admittedly less elaborate than the one proposed by the Robertson Panel, hardly succeeded in quashing public interest. (Ruppelt, 1956, p.87). The disinformation campaign itself may have served to stimulate public interest, since it was obvious to many observers that the Air Force was being less than candid. This may be one of the “ironies” to which Jones (1968b) has referred: the process of concealment itself arouses interest in what is being concealed.
Conclusion
In forming his opinion as to whether or not UFOs are in fact “real” — whether extraterrestrial, ultraterrestrial, or whatever — the layman cannot be expected to weigh all of the considerations we have advanced here about the way in which social intelligence about anomalous phenomena is formed. The scientist is likely to be more concerned with those aspects of the phenomena about which he does find out, and to which he can apply the sorts of measurements and methods that to many scientists and laymen alike constitute science. Persons whose responsibilities are less easily circumscribed, such as the social critic and the policy-maker, however, cannot excuse themselves on the basis of either limited sophistication or specialised expertise. In making decisions about anomalous phenomena, they must take into account the network of social information which is responsible for keeping public and government informed about the external world. Mass hysteria over hoaxes and hallucinations constitutes only one danger; the opposite danger is ignoring forces which may have unsought effects on human life.
Notes:
- The wording of the question in this way was unfortunate, because we do not know how many people reported sightings to no one at all; there is evidence, as we shall see below, that those who have such experiences by themselves are re-luctant to report them even to family members.
- One does not know how many sightings are multiple witness. Even if figures were available they might indicate selective reporting; multiple witness sightings being preferentially reported.
- Not to mention having to change jobs or locations as a result of adverse publicity. (Lee, 1968, p.225)
- For instance, airline pilots tend to believe other airline pilots (Ruppelt, p.108 et seq.); generals tend to believe other generals (Op cit. p.125); radar operators tend to believe other radar operators (Op cit., p.169). This tendency is probably stronger the more elite the group.
- From the Smithsonian “Prairie” meteorite camera network.
- He did this by circulating in “flap” areas talking to people in the vicinity, etc.
- This was the case in the UFO wave of 1947, in which several sightings took place before Kenneth Arnold’s famous one (see Bloecher, 1967).
References:
- BLOECHER, TED, 1967. Report on the UFO Wave of 1947. NICAP.
- CANTRIL, HADLEY, 1966. The Invasion from Mars, A Study in the Psychology of Panic. Harper & Row.
- CONDON, EDWARD U., 1968 “UFOs 1947-1968″ and “Conclusions and Recommendations”, in Scientific Study of Unidentified Flying Objects, edited by Daniel S Gilmour. New York, Bantam Books.
- FULLER, JOHN, 1966. Incident at Exeter. New York, G P Putnam’s Sons.
- GILMOUR, DANIEL S., ed., Scientific Study of Unidentified Flying Objects. 1968. Bantam.
- HARTMANN, WILLIAM K., 1968. “Processes of Perception, Conception, and Reporting”. In Condon Report. (Scientific Study of Unidentified Flying Objects, cit supra)
- HEUVELMANS, BERNARD, 1968. In the Wake of the Sea-Serpents. New York: Hill & Wang.
- HOVLAND, CARL, IRVING L JANIS, & HAROLD H KELLEY, 1953. Communication & Persuasion. New Haven: Yale University Press.
- IRVING, DAVID, 1964. The Mares Nest. Boston: Little, Brown.
- JONES, R V., 1968a. “The Natural Philosophy of Flying Saucers”. Physics Bulletin 19: 225-230. , 1968b. “Irony as a Phenomenon in Natural Science and Human Affairs”. Chemistry and Industry: 470-477.
- KEEL, JOHN, 1970. UFOs: Operation Trojan Horse. New York: G P Putnam’s Sons.
- KERCKHOFF, ALAN C., and KURT W. BACK, 1968. The June Bug: a study of hysterical contagion. New York: Appleton, Century, Crofys.
- LEE, ALDORA, 1968. “Public Attitudes Towards UFO Phenomena”. In Condon Report.
- MENZEL, DONALD, 1960. “Flying Saucers”. Encyclopedia of Science and Technology. New York: McGraw-Hill.
- MICHEL, AIME, 1958. Flying Saucers and the Straight Line Mystery. New York: S G Phillips.
- MUENSTERBERG, HUGO, 1915. On the Witness Stand. Garden City; Doubleday.
- National Amateur Astronomers, Inc., 1969. Science and the UFO: A supplement to the Proceedings of the Third Nationwide Amateur Astronomers Convention. Denver, Colorado.
- PAGE, THORNTON, 1968. “Photographic Sky Coverage for Detection of UFOs”. Science 160 (14th June): 1258-1260.
- RUPPELT, EDWARD J., 1956. The Report on UFOs. New York: Ace Books.
- SCHWARTZ, BERTHOLD E., 1972. “Beauty of the Night” FSR 18,4: PP-5-9, 17.
- STRENTZ, HERBERT, 1970. A Survey of Press Coverage of UFOs 1947-1968. Unpublished Doctoral dissertation, Department of Journalism, Northwestern University.
- US HOUSE COMMITTEE on Aeronautics and Astronautics, 1968. Symposium on UFOs. 90th Congress, Second Session (29th July)
- VALLEE, JACQUES, 1969. Passport to Magonia. Chicago: Henry Regnery.
- VALLEE, JACQUES, & V-J BALLESTER OLMOS, 1972. “The Sociology of the Iberian Landings”, FSR 18,4.
- VALLEE, JACQUES & JANINE VALLEE, 1966. Challenge to Science,Chicago; Henry Regnery.
- WARREN, DONALD I., 1970. “Status Inconsistency Theory and Flying Saucer Sightings”. Science 170 (6th November): 599-603.
- WILENSKY, HAROLD L., 1967. Organisational Intelligence. New York: Basic Books.