Monday, 10 March 2014

Concern Over COS-MOS

John Rimmer
Merseyside UFO Bulletin, volume 4, number 1, Spring 1971.

After the publication of his article about the general uselessness of British UFO groups, The Death and Life of British Ufology, in MUFOB volume 3, number 3, John Rimmer was challenged by Norman Oliver, Director of COS-MOS, (COntact Space-Men Or Saucers)  to address a meeting of the Society on this topic. He accepted, and here is his impression of the meeting which he addressed on 27 February 1971.

It was a clear, cool Kensington evening. After a pleasant meal at a neighbouring trattoria my companion and I strolled through the elegant, tree-lined streets of the Royal Borough towards the Central Library, an imposing brick building in the Municipal-Fascist style of architecture.

Following directions I descended a ramp, and entered the building through the basement goods entrance. The brown wood and cork-lined lecture theatre, windowless, was suitably Kafkaesque for what was to follow.

People came strolling in, past the statutory table selling books and magazines. After a quarter of an hour of confusion trying to find who was running the show I took my place on the platform. I found to my surprise that I was confronted by an impressive phalanx of microphones, attached to even more impressive looking tape recorders. I felt like a witness at the McCarthy investigations, broadcasting coast-to-coast on NBC, CBS and ABC.

Norman Oliver, who had invited me to the meeting, was apparently having trouble with trains in Neasden [or London Bridge, as we found out later], so I was introduced by another COS-MOS committeeman.

I began my address by modestly comparing my own views on the futility of UFO groups with those of Dr Jacques Vallee. The main drift of my argument will already be familiar to those who read my original “Death and Life” article, and my reply to Dick Beet’s letter. Basically that I thought UFO organisations were too much organisation and not enough research. I stressed that ufologists should not work in isolation, but that by organising into formal groups they were in danger of dissipating their energies into the complexities of group politics, rather than concentrating on the phenomena.


I attempted to show that the public attitude to ufologists – that they are a crowd of nuts – was in large measure due to the fact that the ufologists the public sees and hears most, were a crowd of nuts, and  I concluded by suggesting that UFO groups may provide some degree of mental satisfaction for those whose particular emotional inadequacies can be sublimated by immersion in the small, complex world of mini-Machiavellianism and big-fishism. Even so there are better ones available in other fields.

The chairman invited questions: "You have a very good turn of phrase, have you ever thought of being a theatre critic?”

This was not quite the sort of question I had been expecting. Despite the theatricality of many UFO events, I confessed that this idea had never crossed my mind. After this the questions came, thick and fast. Or, rather, the speeches came thick and fast. This was when I began to notice a remarkable phenomenon. It appeared that practically no one in the hall had heard a single word I had said!

There seemed to be an assumption that I had forbidden ufologists from ever meeting each other to work together, or even just to meet for a chat and a pint! Some people seemed to think I said UFO work should be abandoned altogether. At first I thought these people might be confused by the verbal virtuosity and epigrammatic brilliance of my speech. But then I realised their confusion was a result of non-communication. What I had been saying was so at odds with their accepted articles of faith that they were incapable of relating to it. They found it easier to assume I had said something else.

About half way through question time came the trick question. “What do you think is the more important, the study of the witness or the study of the UFO?”

This question had nothing whatever to do with anything I had been saying. I said I thought it was irrelevant and a trick question. And like a sucker I proceeded to answer it. This was what they had come to hear. I explained, with much hedging and ifs and buts, that one was forced to study the witness, because the witness was part of the phenomenon. Staunch friends came to my aid, explaining that our only knowledge of the phenomenon was through reports made by witnesses.

It was useless, I had said the wrong thing. I felt like the man in the old Bateman cartoons who asked for a whisky and soda at the Great Pump Room, Bath, or who lit a cigar before the Royal Toast. I was accused of being that most hated of ufological bogey-men – a sceptic.

“Sceptical of what”, I protested, “sceptical of one theory (ETH) of the origin of UFOs?”

To no avail, the die was cast, the chips were down, the cards were on the table. The credibility gap was a yawning abyss.
I moved on, discussing the public image of the ufologist. His strange quirks and aberrations, the funny exhibitions, strange conferences and inane envelope stickers (Who are they supposed to be read by, the postmen?). I had not realised envelope stickers had such devoted aficionados. All the usual cliches and unwarranted assumptions were trotted out: “A well-ordered UFO research network is essential for gathering information on sightings.” I tried to imagine such a network, zeroing in on some little man who had the misfortune to see a UFO. I thought it an extremely unlikely scenario. The audience seemed to imagine it happened all the time.

Next came the great persecution complex and neurotic ego-trip. MIB do not trouble British ufologists. Their enemies are the pressmen. Unscrupulous Lunchtime O’Booze characters who lose no opportunity to ridicule hard-working ufologists. Has it never occurred to them, I asked, that the press portrayed ufologists as crazy because some of them did crazy things? No, of course not, it was a conspiracy aided and abetted by film producers who made films about saucers full of nasty aliens.

Perhaps they only made films about saucers full of nasty aliens because ufologists started putting it around that saucers were filled with aliens, nasty or otherwise. “Nonsense!” announced one gentleman. Had I never read H.G.Wells? He did not seem convinced when I assured him I had. No, the truth is, apparently, that reporters, film producers and television directors decided, quite arbitrarily, to ridicule ufology and all who sail in her. Arbitrarily? Or was it Government Pressure, it was hinted darkly.

By now the congregation was getting restless. “Waste of time, all this, waste of time”, someone muttered. I was saying all the wrong things. Everyone knew that UFO groups were a good thing. “You know, John”, I was told gently, “it takes an awful lot of hard work, by a group, to put out a magazine.”

Lumps came to throats, eyes misted over. Suddenly I felt curmudgeonly, attacking something so obviously dear to the hearts of so many nice people. But I was soon comforted: “You are very brave to come along here and say all this”, I was told by a charming, elderly lady, “and I do think you are terribly sincere”.

“Yes, very sincere”, others echoed, “and you have a marvellous turn of phrase!”

At the interval Mr Oliver appeared. We unfortunately had to leave and were prevented from hearing his talk on “UFO abductions and reproductions”. I just hope there were no film producers in the audience to hear about that!